An audit committee is not there to re-perform the audit. Its members do not test transactions or rebuild the accounts. Their job is narrower and, in some ways, harder: to be satisfied that the financial statements, the controls behind them and the external auditor can be relied on.
When they cannot, the committee's job is to say so plainly: to management, to the full board and, where required, to shareholders.
Three things to rely on
The financial statements. Are the accounting policies appropriate? Are the significant judgments and estimates reasonable, consistently applied and clearly disclosed? Does the narrative match the numbers?
The controls. Does management have a sound basis for the figures it reports? Does the committee know where the weaknesses are and what is being done about them?
The external auditor. Is the auditor independent, properly resourced and willing to challenge management? Does the committee hear the auditor's views directly, without management in the room?
The audit committee does not need to know every number. It needs to know which numbers depend on judgment, and whether that judgment can be trusted.
Focus on judgment
Most of the risk in a set of accounts sits in a small number of areas: revenue recognition, provisions, impairment, valuations and tax positions. A good committee asks management to set out those judgments early, with the alternatives considered, and asks the auditor where it pushed back and why. Surprises at year end usually mean these conversations happened too late.
Own the auditor relationship
In listed companies, the audit committee is generally responsible for appointing, overseeing and setting the fees of the external auditor, and for approving non-audit services. In private companies the formal rules are lighter, but the principle is the same: the auditor should see the committee as its client, not management.
In practice that means regular private sessions with the auditor, a clear view of any non-audit work and the fees attached to it, and a candid annual assessment of the quality of the audit.
Know the limits
The committee should also be clear about what it cannot see. Internal audit, where it exists, is its main source of independent assurance inside the business, and its plan should reflect the risks the committee cares about. Where there is no internal audit function, the committee should ask how else it gets comfort, and whether that is enough.
Finally, members need the background to do the work. Listing standards typically require every audit committee member to be financially literate, and in the United States a listed company must disclose whether at least one member is an audit committee financial expert. Whatever the rules say, a committee that cannot read the accounts critically cannot do its job.





