Whether a director counts as independent is usually decided by a checklist: no employment, no consulting fees, no close family ties. Those tests matter, and they differ according to the rules that apply to each company.
But a checklist cannot tell you whether a director will actually speak up. That depends on incentives.
Follow the incentives
Warren Buffett argued in his Berkshire Hathaway shareholder letters that a director who relies on board fees can be less independent in practice than a director whose own wealth is tied to the company’s success. Four questions help:
How much of this person’s income comes from the seat?
Do they own shares, and did they buy them with their own money?
Do they have any other relationship with the company or its owners?
Have they ever disagreed with management in a way that changed a decision?
Formal and practical independence
A director can pass every independence test and still not challenge management.
Formal independence is a requirement for some boards and a sensible discipline for all of them. Practical independence is what makes the seat worth having. A company should look for both, and be open about the difference.





